[identity profile] gardendoor.livejournal.com posting in [community profile] ship_manifesto
Title: Bang! Holy Grail Time
Author: Gardendoor
Spoilers: Through end of Sentinel, minor spoilage for SG-1 1st season and Meridian
Email: gardendoor AT hotmail DOT com
Personal Website: The Gardendoor Fan Fiction Archive



While many writers attempt crossovers, some more successfully than others, it's unusual to find a pairing that is both highly popular and easy to write. Blair Sandburg and Daniel Jackson, though, fit the bill perfectly. When I first read this pairing, I'd actually never seen either show, and had never even met the SG-1 crew in fanfic, but I was struck by how the two characters complemented each other, how they comforted each other, helped each other gain perspective and find their way past seemingly impossible, life-changing obstacles: the loss of a wife, the death of a career, years of unrequited love for a seemingly indifferent partner.

Blair and Daniel are both crackpot theorists whose theories were unexpectedly proven right, ripping them from quests for dry, dusty footnotes to the shock of life-or-death reality. They each find themselves risking their necks and even dying for their best friends, gruff military-types who jokingly disparage them as geeks. They're both extraordinarily bright and energetic, throw themselves wholeheartedly into their work, and go toe-to-toe with people when their principles are stepped on. And both are spiritual seekers who keep an open mind about the supernatural. Even their quirky backgrounds lend themselves easily to connection, always the hardest sell in any crossover: Daniel Jackson was orphaned at an early age, Blair Sandburg's flaky single mother could easily have left him with friends or lost custody of him temporarily, making it plausible for the two boys to have grown up together. But as they've both studied in obscure libraries and traveled extensively to exotic backwaters, they could meet up any number of ways.

Despite the many similarities, though, Blair and Daniel aren't clones. They aren't even equals. While Daniel gets ribbed for not being military and being a bit of a geek, he's a PhD who knows dozens of languages and cultures. He's one of the two amazing brains of the team, and is respected for his unique strengths by his teammates. Despite his academic background, he's never objected to carrying a gun as part of SG-1, or even using said gun. He's been described as the conscience of SG-1, and he does fight for his convictions, but he's a cultural relativist, rarely objecting to offensive customs within another culture, only within his own. For example, while he's completely against the Goa'uld or anyone else enslaving or wiping out a culture, when facing cultures that seem to believe in marital rape (Broca Divide) or the death penalty (Cor-Ai), he seems content to just observe and analyze unless goaded by his friends into action. But the real kicker of inequities is that while Blair is the one who meditates, the one who has been charged with the responsibility of shaman, Daniel is the one who has ascended to a higher plane and learned the secrets of the universe. The only time Blair even had a vision was when he was piggy-backing on Jim's.

Blair was a child prodigy but tapered off, and is still struggling to get his doctorate at age thirty despite starting college at 16. He has to fight to be heard by Jim and the Major Crimes department, even when he's proven right over and over. He hates guns, preferring to use his wits or handy pieces of furniture to defeat any criminals stalking him. He's hyper where Daniel is mellow, the eager kid brother. And despite his many years as an anthropologist, he's anything but relative when it comes to ethics; he'll jump right in there if he feels someone's being hurt or taken advantage of. Usually when he's paired with Daniel he's relieved by the opportunity to be treated with respect and gentleness by someone who shares his interests. But Blair has something Daniel does not: He knows, because of the Sentinel-Guide link, that he is irreplaceable to Jim, no matter what frictions divide them. Jim will always need his Guide. Daniel has no such assurances from Jack, and is also stuck in the "Don't ask, don't tell" trap that could cost both him and Jack their careers as members of SG-1 if they even raised the possibility of a relationship.

The advantage of a similar-but-not-the-same pairing is that Blair and Daniel each know where the other is coming from, and they can see in each other's lives a glimpse of how their own lives could be different. They can goad each other into changing course or pulling themselves out of a rut because they're alike enough to know exactly which arguments will best persuade. But because of their work commitments and their wanderlust natures, this pairing lends itself more easily to on-again, off-again romance or wacky, one-time comedic disasters, not pledging undying love and setting up housekeeping. Dangermouse was my first introduction to the joy of Daniel/Blair, and Caro Dee's Dog Series is also really good. Learning Experience was a cute glimpse into an early B/D ship, and I've always liked the way Tryst shows how they can help each other and find common ground even when they aren't the primary pairing.

Date: 2004-09-21 06:27 am (UTC)
beccaelizabeth: my Watcher tattoo in blue, plus Be in red Buffy style font (Default)
From: [personal profile] beccaelizabeth
I agree the two have a lot in common. But you seem to be writing about fanon Blair and Daniel, and slash fanon at that. In canon they arent in love with their partners, just good friends. And while it is canon that a Sentinel needs a partner, I think the Sentinel-Guide bond is largely a fanon creation, as is the idea that the Guide is irreplaceable. Jim is cranky and does not play well with others, so anyone being his partner would be tricky, but as long as someone knew as much about his needs as a Sentinel as Blair does theres nothing in canon to say they couldnt be his backup.

Date: 2004-09-21 08:14 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] castalie.livejournal.com
Okay, since I replied twice to a comment but didn't comment on your essay as such, I think it's only fair I do it now lol

I was surprised when I saw this essay because I hadn't even thought of a cross-over ship around here, but if there was one to choose, I'd say that Blair/Daniel is indeed the one *g*

SG and TS are two of my three main fandoms and as you can imagine, I read this pairing now and then, because even though we all know that Daniel belongs to Jack and Blair to Jim --well, us SG and TS slashers, I mean-- I appreciate the take at their relationship. It's usually full of cliches, too but what the hell, a cliche isn't always a bad thing and I just like how sweet and hot they are together, how easy-going their relationship is, and how it never really threatens their love for their respective partners. It's like a win-win situation lol

Also, I'm glad you rec'ced Tryst even though Blair/Daniel isn't exactly the main pairing, because that's one of my favourite TS/SG story *g*

Date: 2004-09-21 04:52 pm (UTC)
ext_3954: (Default)
From: [identity profile] alicambs.livejournal.com
I adore Daniel Jackson, but find Blair Sandburg somewhat annoying and have never got into the Sentinel fandom. That said, I found your essay interesting and liked you summary of their similarities and differences. You made a good case and I was intrigued enough to look up your recs, only to find that I'd read a couple of them Tryst being the one I remember enjoying the most.

Date: 2004-09-21 05:16 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] porntestpilot.livejournal.com
Well I have seen this pairing before, Dangermouse I think? But hey, I worship Blair and Daniel as gods basically so them shagging is quite fine by me.

Nice write-up and excellent, fic I may not have read!

Date: 2009-07-15 04:20 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] jen-chan13.livejournal.com
oh my god, YES. i haven't even read it yet - will get back to you - but holy god, YES!!!

Date: 2010-04-26 03:28 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] wingslapped.livejournal.com
I've seen this pairing around, and I like it.

There are a few stories tagged with this pairing on delicious. There has to be more out there.

http://delicious.com/tag/daniel%2Fblair

http://delicious.com/tag/blair%2Fdaniel

Profile

ship_manifesto: (Default)
ship_manifesto

January 2012

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
222324 25262728
293031    

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 11th, 2025 03:50 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios